How will this system be workable for managers with half a dozen sides in a game? Will their Karma points be pooled? Would we have a system where I, for example, could run Ternana, Sittard and Gothenburg but exclusively use the Karma points to heal Honved?
I'm not of the belief that points for posts is workable to any great extent. It's different with transfers as they are attributable to a definite club.

I think it's already been said (somewhere) that clubs will be treated separately. So your 3 clubs would accumulate their own points. Rather than you accumulating points for all 3 of them.

Personally think its a great idea, more posts equal more activity. A manager doesn't want to post In a certain section or doesn't want to get involved in a section then he doesn't have to. Its a choice.

Like i previously posted, managers who post less often or don't bother partaking in any extra forum activities will obviously oppose to the idea and moan that others are rewarded 'more' than them as a result, where as the more frequent posters and partakers will always go with and be rewarded which is right and fair.

End of the day you don't get nothing for free in this life, so the more work you put in the more you will be rewarded. Can't be more simpler than that.

Alternatively if you wanted to look at it a different way, maybe award different amount of points for different sections, like this....

We all like results section, so maybe a post here would be 20 karma points, moving to maybe what would be second most inviting section namely swap section which could be 15, sales being 10 with General which is considered used less frequent with less interesting topics and threads banking you just a point per post peraps.

Whats everyone's thoughts?

This way the lesser posters can be rewarded the dame amount of posts as a frequent poster by just posting in only the more attractive topics.

Before I state my opinion I would like to note that I am one of the highest active posters, with that said... I'm totally against the idea of points for ALL posts.

I think in principle forum activity being rewarded would be a great idea, but in a controlled manner!

For example, points could be gained for the following...

- completing turn sent section
- completing deals agreed section
- posting results in the team results section
- posting squads up in the my team part

That along with MDS sending, and the various other points made by UE would be more then sufficient!

Also the extra points for those who run forum cups etc isn't a bad idea either. Perhaps an amount for those who run it and a smaller amount for those who partake?

So say if a forum cup is run, the manager who creates and runs it earns 200 points at the end of a month or a set amount of turns, those who partake get 50 points which. Those who partake can be confirmed as having done so to ue by the manager running the side game.

I don't think all posts should accumulate karma points. Maybe just for results, squad threads etc. Where you can only gain a certain amount of points per turn. Rather then daily for posting crap no one cares about.

There could be etiquette threads in some sections of the forum like cash deals, saying there should only be one post per team per turn. If a manager is justifiably reported as spamming that forum with lots of unnecessary threads, they could lose Karma.

Please don't take this as an offence bud, but i couldn't help but notice that yes overall you are one of the most posters, but since very early April you have posted just a dozen times which averages about 2 posts a week up to date. In fact all your 12 posts since April 7th were done on 4 different days of the 29 total days since. That isn't really an avid poster anymore really? which goes with my point i made a few days ago about the lesser posters tend to not want all posts to be rewarded.

It's a big fat NO from me despite if it became a reality then I would take massive advantage and have 1000 Karma points very quickly to give a player versatility. Whilst I love the forum being busy and vibrant that time has passed and we are at a new age where Whatsapp has taken over. I'm not a big Whatsapp poster and in fact am only in one group now as I quite honestly haven't got the time to keep up. Filling the forum with drizzle will not help and could in fact cause issues in my opinion.

firstly, id like to say congrats darth and sorry for your loss too!

i would consider myself a newbie so I'm not sure if my comments will carry any weight, but consider this as a new players feedback..